John Paul II on evolution

JHOFMANN@ccvax.fullerton.edu
Sat, 07 Dec 1996 21:04:03 -0800 (PST)

Greetings:
I'm wondering if anyone else besides me has been perturbed by the
apparent serious discrepancy between the version of the Pope's statement
on evolution quoted in US newspapers and the full statement as made
available on the web by New Advent Catholic Supersite. The full version was
published in the October 30 edition of _L'Osservatore Romano_. The passage
I am interested in appeared in section 4:

"... new knowledge has led to the recognition of more than one hypothesis
in the theory of evolution."

The US media version reads as follows:

"...new knowledge leads us to recognize in the theory of evolution more
than a hypothesis."

I assume that we are confronted by two translations of a non-English text
and there probably is a pesky indefinite pronoun at fault. My own feeling
is that the "more than a hypothesis" version fits the context of
the full text better than the "more than one hypothesis" version.
Does anyone have some definitive information on the original
text and its subsequent translations?
Jim Hofmann California State University Fullerton
jhofmann@fullerton.edu