Some (Art Chadwick, and at least one other) who complained about
the "lack of review" -- it's not clear whether they were talking
about the newsgroup or the archive. As far as the archive
is concerned: (1) I have submitted the FAQs which I wrote (for
example The Age of the Earth [1] and Isochron Dating [2] FAQs)
to numerous experts in several fields -- and several young-Earth
creationists -- for review; and (2) aside from the primary
literature (which is also not the right place to send a newbie)
the lack of *formal* review could be used to criticize *any*
source.
[1] http://www.talkorigins.org/faqs/faq-age-of-earth.html
[2] http://www.talkorigins.org/faqs/isochron-dating.html
Anyone in this list is welcome to take a crack at the above. I
will make adjustments for any errors which are pointed out. You
can send feedback via the talkorigins.org "feedback" forms or via
E-mail directly to me at "chris@stassen.com".
-- Chris (chris@stassen.com)