Re: Scientists Defend Research Against Charles Tirade

From: Stephen E. Jones (sejones@iinet.net.au)
Date: Tue May 30 2000 - 17:33:31 EDT

  • Next message: Susan Brassfield: "Re: Suspicions aroused..."

    Reflectorites

    Here are excerpts from Yahoo! for the period 9-26 May 2000, with my
    comments in square brackets.

    Steve

    =====================================================
    http://dailynews.yahoo.com/h/nm/20000518/sc/britain_charles_2.html
    Yahoo! ... May 18 ... Scientists Defend Research Against Charles Tirade ...
    LONDON (Reuters) - Tampering with nature is an affront to God, says
    Britain's Prince Charles. Rubbish, say scientists who argue they are saving
    humanity by helping to feed the world more efficiently. But few would
    argue with the timing of his latest "green salvo," launched during a BBC
    lecture ... The heir to the throne fanned the flames over biotechnology with
    an impassioned defense of nature on a day British farmers discovered they
    had been unknowingly growing genetically modified crops after buying
    contaminated oilseed from Canada. Charles, surrounded by green gurus,
    warns of the "disastrous consequences" of cloning and GM food. Tabloid
    newspapers rail against "Frankenstein Food." .... Plant scientist Chris
    Leaver dismissed the future king's comments, saying: "He has selective
    religious beliefs to suit his own lifestyle and should be careful of preaching
    to others." ... he bluntly told Charles to listen to the scientists trying to find
    ways of feeding six billion people on the planet today and another three
    billion by the year 2050. Leading geneticist Sir Walter Bodmer launched a
    passionate defense of GM food technology. "The potential it offers for
    solving the problems that face the so-called Third World is enormous," he
    wrote in the same paper. Across the scientific spectrum, the message was
    the same. ... Steve Jones, professor of genetics ... said Charles was a
    woolly thinker. "He is mixing up theology and science. The best thing he
    should do is go back to school...I have no time for understanding people
    who prefer ignorance to knowledge," .... Prince Charles is a fiercely
    committed environmentalist. And he adds to the potentially explosive green
    cocktail an ever widening interest in the spiritual thinking of many differing
    religions. Those passionately held views were spelled out Wednesday in a
    BBC lecture that stirred up a fierce ecological debate. "Nature has come to
    be regarded as a system that can be engineered for our own
    convenience...and in which anything that happens can be fixed by
    technology and human ingenuity," Charles complained. "If literally nothing
    is held sacred any more...what is there to prevent us treating our entire
    world as some great laboratory of life with potentially disastrous
    consequences?" When he eventually takes over as King and Supreme
    Governor of the Anglican Church of England, Charles sees himself as
    "Defender of Faith" in a country that is a multicultural mix. And his plea for
    spirituality in a consumer-driven society did not fall entirely on deaf ears.
    "Thank Heavens for Prince Charles," said Professor Jonathan Sacks, Chief
    Rabbi of the United Hebrew Congregation of the Commonwealth. "Once
    again he has introduced a note of sanity into our scientific future. He has
    made us stop, think and question where we are going." See also:
    http://dailynews.yahoo.com/h/nm/20000517/sc/britain_charles_1.html
    Yahoo! ... May 17 ... Britain's Prince Charles Warns Modern Science
    LONDON (Reuters) - Britain's Prince Charles on Wednesday will warn
    that the world faces environmental disaster unless it starts accepting that
    tampering with nature is an affront to God. The heir-to-the-throne ... will
    use a lecture broadcast on BBC radio to make a wider attack on some
    methods employed by modern science. "We need to rediscover a reverence
    for the natural world, irrespective of its usefulness to ourselves, to become
    more aware of the relationship between God, man and creation," he will
    say. "If literally nothing is held sacred anymore, what is there to prevent us
    treating our entire world as some 'great laboratory of life' with potentially
    disastrous long-term consequences? ... "Only by rediscovering the essential
    unity and order of the living and spiritual world and by bridging the gap
    between cynical secularism and the timelessness of traditional religion will
    we avoid the disintegration of our environment." ... However, the
    zoologist, Professor Richard Dawkins, said the emphasis of the prince's
    attack was wrong. "I have great sympathy with Prince Charles's mission
    and his desire to foster stewardship of the planet," he said. "But to attack
    science in so doing is the wrong way to go about it. Science should be
    harnessed as his ally both in method and in way of thinking." ... [I am
    amused by my namesake's hypocritical complaint that Charles "...is mixing
    up theology and science'! What does Jones think he and his Darwinist
    cronies have been doing all this time with their incessant pontifications on
    God? And it is a bit rich Dawkins saying that "Science should be harnessed
    as his ally...". This is from a Professor for the Public Understanding of
    Science who has stated that those who don't believe in evolution are
    "insane" or "wicked" and who has described religion as a "virus of the
    mind"! And as for being "a woolly thinker", the materialists like Jones and
    Dawkins don't seem to be able to make the simple logical distinction
    between a criticism of the attitude and methods of some scientists and an
    attack on science itself! Presumably this is because to materialists, there
    *is* no such distinction. It is pleasing to see the dominant materialistic-
    naturalistic mindset of most scientists being questioned by other voices,
    especially one with such access to the media and eventually government as
    Prince Charles! These other voices will probably be allies when the ID
    movement's Wedge strategy of separating materialistic-naturalistic
    philosophy from science becomes more widely known.]

    http://dailynews.yahoo.com/h/nm/20000517/sc/health_conflicts_2.html
    Yahoo! ... May 17 ... Industry Influence May Taint Drug Studies-Journal
    ... BOSTON (Reuters) - Drug companies that pay for research and clinical
    tests of new medicines have been suppressing or manipulating the results, a
    report in Thursday's New England Journal of Medicine said. The
    prestigious, peer-reviewed Journal also warned the likelihood that drug test
    results will be manipulated or suppressed is even greater when for-profit
    companies set up specifically to test drugs conduct the trials. The findings
    appear in an article, "Uneasy Alliance -- Clinical Investigators and the
    Pharmaceutical Industry," .... In the depression study, so many authors had
    potential conflicts of interest, the Journal decided for space reasons not to
    publish the complete list...a sharply worded editorial where Dr. Marcia
    Angell raises the question "Is Academic Medicine For Sale?" appears one
    week after the Journal's publisher, the Massachusetts Medical Society,
    announced it would replace her as editor with a prominent asthma
    researcher who has strong ties to the drug industry. ... the industry is
    wielding more power in conducting large-scale drug tests ... when drug
    companies control the purse strings, they "may design studies likely to
    favor their product..." ... academic-industry drug trials have been tainted by
    the profit incentive," ... "There is now considerable evidence that
    researchers with ties to drug companies are indeed more likely to report
    results that are favorable to the products of those companies," .... Last
    week, the Massachusetts Medical Society, which owns the Journal, named
    asthma researcher Dr. Jeffrey M. Drazen as the new editor, replacing
    Angell.... Drazen ... who has received grants or consultation fees from nine
    pharmaceutical companies, defended alliances between researchers and
    drug companies ... [The obvious question then is "what about HIV-AIDS"?
    One doesn't have to be a conspiracy theorist to suspect that a multi-billion
    dollar drug industry which almost totally funds HIV-AIDS research is
    likely to exert an influence on researchers to come up with results that
    support those treatments which maximise corporate profits (e.g. expensive
    multiple drug cocktails).]

    http://dailynews.yahoo.com/h/nm/20000512/sc/aids_drugs_3.html Yahoo!
    ... May 12 ... Experts Say AIDS Drug Deal Still Needs Work ... LONDON
    (Reuters) - A surprise announcement that major drug firms will slash prices
    to tackle the world's AIDS epidemic is a vital first step to saving millions of
    lives but leaves many questions open... Two years after being castigated at
    the last international AIDS meeting for not doing enough to curb AIDS in
    the developing world, five of the biggest drug companies promised
    Thursday to cut prices in a deal brokered by the United Nations. But there
    are still few details of those cuts, of how much money may now be made
    available by international donors, or of how the drugs will be administered
    in chaotic health systems. ... Although the drugs are expected to be sold at
    a fraction of their original cost, they may still be too expensive for sub-
    Saharan Africa ... See also:
    http://dailynews.yahoo.com/h/nm/20000511/sc/aids_usa_1.html Yahoo! ...
    May 11 ... Annan Praises U.S. Pledge on AIDS Help for Africa UNITED
    NATIONS (Reuters) - Secretary-General Kofi Annan praised ... President
    Clinton's signing of an executive order that will help make cheaper AIDS
    drugs available to millions of patients in sub-Saharan Africa. ... Clinton
    promised that U.S. officials would not stand in the way of countries
    seeking to obtain less costly AIDS medication for their poorest citizens ...
    The U.S. announcement followed a campaign by AIDS activists who have
    complained that the Clinton administration was working on behalf of U.S.
    drug makers to bully developing countries into dropping their pursuit of
    generic drugs. ... &
    http://dailynews.yahoo.com/h/nm/20000511/sc/aids_drugs_1.html Yahoo!
    ... May 11 ... AIDS Drug Makers Slash Prices for Third World ...
    GENEVA (Reuters) - Five top drugs companies agreed Thursday to slash
    the price of HIV and AIDS treatments for developing countries in a
    breakthrough U.N. deal that could save millions of lives in Africa. ... For
    the drugs firms, the deal is a shrewd marketing move. It may relieve some
    of the public pressure from AIDS activists in the West who have
    campaigned for drugs against the pandemic in the developing world, angry
    at policies that priced medicines beyond the reach of the poor. "This will go
    down very nicely as positive public relations for all companies involved," ...
    the move was unlikely to have a commercial impact. AIDS is now the
    leading killer in sub-Saharan Africa, where 23.3 million people have HIV,
    the virus that causes it. ... U.S. pharmaceutical companies had argued that
    countries' efforts to license local manufacturers to make generic copies of
    AIDS drugs violated the firms' patent protection and compromised future
    research. U.S. officials had threatened trade sanctions against countries that
    pursued such licenses for patented drugs. ... [So it is no coincidence that
    after years of stalling the drug companies are now going to make their
    products cheaper, just as South Africa starts its inquiry into HIV-AIDS? If
    the drug companies really thought their drugs saved lives, how could they
    sit back while reaping huge profits in Western countries, keeping their
    prices too high for African countries to afford, all the while knowing that
    tens of millions of human lives were being lost unnecessarily? Especially
    since making them cheaper "was unlikely to have a commercial impact"!
    Either they don't believe their drugs work, or they are moral monsters. And
    what about the morality of the US government even *considering*
    threatening trade sanctions against African countries which tried to make
    generic versions of the drugs they could not afford in a desperate attempt
    to save their people's lives?]

    http://dailynews.yahoo.com/h/nm/20000525/sc/earth_iceage_1.html ...
    Yahoo! ... May 25 ... Surviving During Earth's Ice Age LONDON
    (Reuters) - Canadian and American scientists think they may have found
    the answer to how life survived on Earth about 600 million years ago when
    the planet resembled a giant snowball. They used calculations and climate
    models to show there may have been areas of open water that allowed
    early creatures to live while the rest of the planet was in a deep freeze...
    about 600-800 million years ago, the Earth was covered by ice and then a
    sudden warming period thawed the deep freeze and led to an important
    period of evolution. ...But they were puzzled by how life could have
    survived and then thrived under such harsh conditions. Peltier and
    colleagues ... believe the harsh climates could have given the creatures an
    evolutionary push. "The extreme climates may even have exerted pressure
    on the multi-celled animals to evolve and adapt, possibly leading to the
    rapid development of new forms of animals and their movement into new,
    unpopulated habitats when the Earth exited the snowball state," said
    Peltier. The researchers used computer simulations of what are thought to
    have been the climate characteristics at the time and took into account less
    sunlight and the varied concentrations of atmospheric carbon dioxide. [This
    simulation might be of some value in explaining how some of the Earth's
    surface was not covered by ice, and may even be a partial explanation of
    the Cambrian Explosion. But merely saying that "harsh climates could have
    given the creatures an evolutionary push" is IMHO just hand-waving.
    There are similar harsh climates on Earth with empty environmental niches
    like the Poles right now and they are not causing "the rapid development of
    new forms of animals".]

    http://dailynews.yahoo.com/h/nm/20000514/sc/environment_madagascar_2
    .html
    Yahoo! ... May 14 ... Madagascar's Jewels of Nature Under Threat ...
    Madagascar (Reuters) - Two lemurs sit huddled together against the rain in
    the upper branches of a Ramy tree, the white-bearded male calling out to
    other members of their group. Sixty-five feet below on the forest floor, a
    ring-tailed mongoose scampers across a narrow path and a snake slithers
    into dense bushes where a Calumma chameleon, found nowhere else on
    earth, clings to a trembling leaf. ... Naturalists describe Madagascar as a
    "Garden of Eden," a place of astounding beauty which, over a period of
    150 million years, evolved a unique array of animal and plant species. But
    humans, who arrived about 2,000 years ago, have over the last century
    destroyed much of that natural wealth. ... It is an environmental disaster
    repeated in countries across the world but is particularly galling in
    Madagascar because more than 80 percent of its tens of thousands of
    animal and plant species are unique to the island. "These are found
    nowhere else. When a species disappears from here, it disappears forever.
    .... Madagascar ... broke off and floated away from the huge continent
    known as Gondwanaland some 150 million years ago. Completely isolated
    from the rest of the world and uninhabited by humans, its unique
    environment allowed the evolution of strange and wonderful animals ...
    Among its unique animals still surviving are 35 species of lemur, dozens of
    species of vividly colored frogs and chameleons, and the small but powerful
    fosa, the lemurs' only predator and pound-for-pound one of the world's
    most efficient killers. Many species, however, have already been lost. They
    include as many as 17 lemur species -some of them as large as gorillas -- as
    well as giant tortoises and the so-called elephant bird which was related to
    the ostrich and, standing 10 feet tall, weighed up to a ton. ... It is not just
    animals that are being lost. Madagascar has more than 10,000 species of
    plants and trees, about 80 percent of them local and many used in
    traditional medicine. As the West looks more closely at herbal medicines
    for possible cures for everything from cancer to allergies, experts say
    Madagascar is an invaluable medicine chest. ... [What a tragedy! But it is
    worth noting that with 150 myrs of isolation, no new higher taxa appear to
    have evolved, just more variations on a limited number of themes, i.e.
    microevolution (so-called).]

    http://dailynews.yahoo.com/h/nm/20000517/sc/science_dinosaur_3.html
    Yahoo! ... May 17 ... Chicago Museum Unveils Landmark Dinosaur ...
    CHICAGO (Reuters) - Dinosaur fever struck Chicago on Wednesday as
    the Field Museum unveiled the most complete Tyrannosaurus rex fossil
    ever found -- a 41 foot-long monster that lumbered the Great Plains 67
    million years ago. ... named "Sue" emerged in a swirl of smoke, music and
    spotlights ... [It] had provided some scientific surprises about the ferocious
    species during the nearly three years it was reassembled bone-by-bone. ...
    One was the presence of a wishbone, the first ever found in a T-rex and
    additional proof for those who believe dinosaurs are related to birds. The
    wishbone is a structure unique to fowl. In addition the fossil is the first of a
    T-Rex ever found with an ear drum bone called a stapes - also found in
    birds - that helps transmit sound to the inner ear ... Sue probably walked at
    a relatively slow gait - about 6 mph -- with a top speed of perhaps 15 mph
    ... but one what would have been swifter than other species roaming the
    land. The animal also and had a keen sense of smell, thanks to huge
    olfactory lobes, leading experts to believe it may have moved through life
    "nose first," but shedding no light on whether it was a predator of a
    scavenger. Of the 20 or so other T-Rex skeletons that have been put
    together around the world, this one is about 90 percent complete... Initial
    indications led experts to believe the T-Rex was a female ... Now that it has
    been assembled, however, paleontologists are not certain of the sex. They
    believe, however, that the creature weighed about seven tons. .... [Since
    birds arose in the Jurassic, about 70 million years before T-Rex, it is hard
    to see what value finding Sue's wishbone and stapes is to understanding the
    origin of birds. I suspect this is just more evolutionist propaganda.]

    http://dailynews.yahoo.com/h/nm/20000515/sc/ants_inbreeding_1.html
    Yahoo! ... May 15 ... Inbreeding May Help Pesky Ants WASHINGTON
    (Reuters) - A species of ant that usually limits its population by waging war
    has made itself into a major pest in the United States using an unusual
    strategy -- inbreeding ... They found colonies of inbred ants were so prolific
    that they are the No. 1 bug pests in parts of California, while the more
    genetically diverse colonies in Argentina are so low-profile they are hard to
    find. ... Tsutsui and biology professor Ted Case described a giant
    "supercolony" of closely related ants living in a swath of territory from San
    Diego to Ukiah, 100 miles (60 km) north of San Francisco. ... "When we
    did our field work in Argentina, it was surprisingly difficult to find
    Argentine ants, compared to our experience in California," ... "They are a
    relatively inconspicuous feature, both in the urban and in the natural
    environment." Tsutsui's team looked at the DNA of both the U.S. and
    Argentine ants and found the South American strains were much more
    genetically diverse. The U.S. ants looked very inbred -- the hallmark of a
    population that has grown from a very few members in what is known as a
    bottleneck. ... the inbred ants may all recognize one another as relatives,
    and may fight and compete less. In Argentina, colonies wage war on one
    another. ... [An interesting example of the Founder Effect? But why hasn't
    natural selection favoured this cooperative strategy in ants before now,
    back in Argentina? Maybe the logical move would be to import more
    Argentine ants from Argentina and dilute this inbred species?]

    http://dailynews.yahoo.com/h/nm/20000509/sc/health_superbug_1.html
    Yahoo! ... May 9 ... Scientists Map Genes of 'Superbug' Bacterium
    WASHINGTON (Reuters) - Researchers said on Tuesday they had finished
    a crucial first step in mapping all the genes of one of the most notorious
    drug-resistant "superbugs" -- Enterococcus faecium. The bacterium is one
    of several that have evolved strains that resist all but the strongest
    antibiotics. ... This new capability to rapidly decode the DNA of microbes
    can be used to provide the scientific community with a huge amount of
    fundamental data about life and the microbial world," ... The work was
    done very quickly, even by the latest standards. The 2.8 million "base pairs"
    -- the nucleotides that pair up to make the twisted ladder of DNA's double
    helix -were sequenced using one day's production capacity at the JGI's
    Sequencing Facility. ... humans have 3 billion base pairs and it took several
    months for scientists to complete the shotgun sequencing of one human
    being. "I've been saying that we could sequence a bacterium in a day," ... "I
    believe this kind of fast response capability could prove to be very useful to
    researchers in medical, national security and agricultural contexts." Once
    each gene is mapped, researchers can look for weaknesses in its defenses to
    exploit. "This research breakthrough paves the way for preventive
    vaccines, in addition to better diagnostic tests and treatments," ....
    Enterococci were now the second most common pathogen found in
    hospital acquired infections ... A new strain, resistant to the last-ditch
    antibiotic vancomycin as well as to more common antibiotics, has emerged.
    ... [This is good news but unfortunately mapping a genome does not itself
    tell how it works. That even a `primitive' bacterium has a 2.8 megabase
    genome sounds like yet another problem for naturalism. Darwinists
    originally hoped that the cell would turn out to be a simple jelly-like blob of
    protoplasm. Now even the simplest one-celled organisms are found to have
    a fully automatic, self-maintaining, self-refuelling, self-propelling, self-
    reproducing, operating system that far exceeds that of a supercomputer in
    sophistication!]

    http://dailynews.yahoo.com/h/nm/20000526/sc/health_nipah_1.html ...
    Yahoo! ... May 26 ... Nipah Virus a Rare New Genus - Study
    WASHINGTON (Reuters) - The Nipah virus that killed 106 people in
    Malaysia and Singapore and caused livestock breeders to slaughter more
    than 1 million pigs in 1999 is a member of a new genus of viruses ... it was
    related to a mysterious virus, since named Hendra virus, that sickened
    horses and killed two people in Australia in 1994.... "We suggest that these
    two viruses are representative of a new genus within the family
    Paramyxoviridae" .... [The origin of a new genus or one that was already
    existing but undetected until it jumped the species barrier?]

    http://dailynews.yahoo.com/h/nm/20000516/sc/health_anger_1.html
    Yahoo! ... May 16 ... Anger An Early Predictor of Heart Problems-US
    Study CHICAGO (Reuters) - Anger and hostility as character traits may
    start damaging the arteries of even young adults, a study said on Tuesday.
    The 10-year study of 374 both black and white adults aged 18 to 30 at the
    start found that those who displayed high levels of anger and hostility were
    more likely to develop artery calcification, a hardening of the arteries that
    may not produce recognizable symptoms but can lead to heart disease ... In
    past studies, mostly of older white males, an angry or hostile personality
    has been shown to increase the risk of high blood pressure, coronary artery
    disease, and death. .... The report also showed that those that displayed an
    attitude of "cynical distrust," described as a less severe form of hostility,
    also had more coronary calcium than those who scored lower on the
    hostility scale, although to a lesser degree than those scoring higher on the
    scale. [Maybe following the Maker's Instruction Manual is best after all? :-
    )]

    http://dailynews.yahoo.com/h/nm/20000512/sc/gender_reassignment_1.ht
    ml
    Yahoo! ... May 12 ... Research Confirms Nature Makes the Man
    WASHINGTON (Reuters) - Two studies ... confirm that nature makes the
    man, and that sex-reassignment surgery for boys born with deformed sex
    organs is misguided and possibly cruel. The studies of 25 genetically male
    children raised as girls because of genital deformities showed all of them
    retained strong male characteristics, despite hormone and other treatments.
    Most reassigned themselves to be males when they got older .... "These
    studies suggest that male gender identity is directly related to normal male
    patterns of male hormone exposure in utero (in the womb)," ... "These
    children demonstrate that normal male gender identity can develop not only
    in the absence of the penis, but even after the removal of testicles or
    castration at birth, and unequivocal rearing as female," ... "Rather than the
    environment forming these children's gender identity, their identity and
    gender role seem to have developed despite a total environment telling
    them they were female." The issue has been prominent lately with the
    publication of a book, "As Nature Made Him," by journalist John
    Colapinto, which chronicles the case of Bruce Thiessen. Thiessen had his
    genitals mutilated during a botched circumcision and his parents were
    convinced to raise him as a girl. The experiment failed, as Thiessen rebelled
    against becoming "Brenda." ..."These studies indicate that with time and
    age, children may well know what their gender is, regardless of any and all
    information and child-rearing to the contrary," Reiner said. "They seem to
    be quite capable of telling us who they are, and we can observe how they
    act and function even before they can tell us." [Another blow to those
    social engineers and feminist extremists who think that human maleness
    and femaleness are just shallow-rooted learned responses which can easily
    be re-oriented by `politically correct' educational and political campaigns.]

    http://dailynews.yahoo.com/h/nm/20000522/sc/science_syria_1.html
    Yahoo! .... May 22 .... U.S.-Syrian Team Find Ancient City in Syria
    CHICAGO (Reuters) - The discovery of an ancient city in Syria indicates
    civilization as marked by urbanization was more widespread and earlier
    than thought, archeologists said on Monday. "We need to reconsider our
    ideas about the beginnings of civilization, pushing the time further back," ...
    "This would mean that the development of kingdoms or early states
    occurred before writing was invented and before the appearance of several
    other criteria we think of as marking civilization," ... The early city, which
    researchers call Tell Hamoukar, was first occupied between 4000 and 3700
    B.C. and covered parts of about 500 acres (200 hectares). From 3700 to
    3500 B.C. it was a wellorganized town enclosed by a wall. ... The time
    periods involved challenge the traditional view that urban civilization first
    blossomed in the Sumerian city-states, such as Uruk, in modern day
    southern Iraq, and then spread through the ancient Near East during the
    Late Uruk period, from 3500 to 3100 B.C. .... Instead the Syrian discovery
    suggests civilization was emerging in both southern Mesopotamia and
    Syria earlier, the researchers said. Archeologists said they found evidence
    of large-scale food-making, including large ovens capable of bread-baking,
    large cooking pots, pottery and traces of wheat, barley, oats and animal
    bones. They also found seals that apparently were used to mark items for
    ownership, including some with elaborate animal designs that might have
    been held by the people with the most authority. ... [More confirmation of
    the Biblical picture of an ancient world far earlier than historians under the
    influence of evolutionary theory had suspected?]
    ======================================================

    --------------------------------------------------------------------------
    "Our willingness to accept scientific claims that are against common sense
    is the key to an understanding of the real struggle between science and the
    supernatural. We take the side of science in spite of the patent absurdity of
    some of its constructs, in spite of its failure to fulfill many of its extravagant
    promises of health and life, in spite of the tolerance of the scientific
    community for unsubstantiated just-so stories, because we have a prior
    commitment, a commitment to materialism. It is not that the methods and
    institutions of science somehow compel us to accept a material explanation
    of the phenomenal world, but, on the contrary, that we are forced by our
    *a priori* adherence to material causes to create an apparatus of
    investigation and a set of concepts that produce material explanations, no
    matter how counter-intuitive, no matter how mystifying to the uninitiated.
    Moreover, that materialism is absolute, for we cannot allow a Divine Foot
    in the door." (Lewontin R., "Billions and Billions of Demons," Review of
    "The Demon-Haunted World: Science as a Candle in the Dark," by Carl
    Sagan, New York Review, January 9, 1997. Emphasis in original.
    http://www.nybooks.com/nyrev/WWWarchdisplay.cgi?19970109028R@p6)
    Stephen E. Jones | sejones@iinet.net.au | http://www.iinet.net.au/~sejones
    --------------------------------------------------------------------------



    This archive was generated by hypermail 2b29 : Tue May 30 2000 - 17:43:16 EDT