Re: [asa] Saving Darwin: What theological changes are required?

>>> "karl.w.giberson@enc.edu" <gibersok@gmail.com> 6/10/2008 8:44 AM >>>
writes:

The theologians and philosophers I talk to all reject dualism.
I am under the impression that it has a negligibly small place in
contemporary discourse. Many biblical scholars consider dualism to be
non-biblical, a Greek idea from Plato that is inconsistent with
Hebraic understandings. The whole point of affirming the
"resurrection of the body" is that there is no other way to recover
the person. If dualism were true, then our immaterial souls could
exist apart from our bodies.

Ted comments:
As my earlier post indicates, Karl and I are apparently not talking to the
same theologians and philosophers.

I entirely agree with Karl about affirming the bodily resurrection, but my
own view of that event, heavily influenced by my own reflection on scripture
and also by NT Wright, is that (so to speak) there is a time in between our
physical death and our re-embodiment in a glorified body. I don't know
whether or not Karl holds this view; perhaps Karl believes that our
re-embodiment is instantaneous (so to speak). If he does share this view,
however, then I would ask him: Karl, where do "you" go in between death and
resurrection (so to speak)? Does God hold you in God's own mind? If so, is
God's mind a material mind or not? Does being held in God's mind count as
being embodied, or not? Either way, what exactly is it that God remembers,
prior to our resurrection? Is it our "form", as the scholastic philosophers
(who weren't stupid) might call it? Is it our "soul"? Even if God
remembers us as embodied creatures, not simply as "forms" or "souls," what
exactly is it in God's mind, in between times? Isn't it something pretty
darn like a "form" or "soul" of you or me?

I don't pretend to have good answers to these really hard questions. Karl
might, in which case I'm all ears. But my overall point here is (again) to
avoid dancing on the gravestone of dualism, when (like Huck Finn), it might
be attending its own funeral.

Ted

To unsubscribe, send a message to majordomo@calvin.edu with
"unsubscribe asa" (no quotes) as the body of the message.
Received on Tue Jun 10 09:33:08 2008