Cornelius Hunter wrote:
>Unfortunately this is always the explanation, and it makes common descent
>unfalsifiable. With every problem, one hears, "well, that doesn't mean the theory is
>wrong." So here we have all kinds of incongruities -- phylogenetic mismatches
>abounding. Non homologous development patterns that make utterly no sense on
>common descent. Detailed designs evolving independently over and over.
And what I find utterly lacking on the part of ID and YEC is a coherent and credible explanation of why the species of life on earth have utterly changed many times over. If you look at the fossil record, you don't see what one would expect from reading the Biblical account. The problem is that only evolution actually explains the complete and total change of species over time. The oldest fossil of a living mammalian species is upper Miocene--around 7 million years ago. Prior to that, not a single living mammalian species can be found as a fossil. And if one goes further back one finds that every 7-15 million years the entire set of species rolls over--an entirely new set of species. This continues back through time for hundreds of millions of years.
Can you please explain why this continuing total change of fauna over time occurs? The average lifespan of a mammalian species is 3 million years. (Steven M. Stanley, "Evolution of LIfe: Evidence for a New Pattern", Great Ideas Today, 1983, (Chicago: Encyclopaedia Britannica,) p. 11)
The Bible gives us no hint of why this happens so anything you say is totally extrabiblical. Some ID folks have said that God was preparing the world for us. If you hold this view, please explain why Man couldn't have eaten trilobites? Why did God require 200 million years for plants to appear on land? Why did God then require another 100 million before complex life to appear? What was he waiting for? Why did his genetic tinkerings take so long? Evolution fits that kind of time scale much better than have a very very slow acting God. Why couldn't mankind have appeared on earth in the Late Paleozoic--240 million years ago? What exactly was God waiting for? When you do explain this, please explain God's reasoning for this species change as well.
---------------------------------
Start your day with Yahoo! - make it your home page
Received on Sun Jul 31 08:14:04 2005
This archive was generated by hypermail 2.1.8 : Sun Jul 31 2005 - 08:14:06 EDT