RE: Make - develop - evolve (was: The firmament ... concordism)

From: Peter Ruest (pruest@pop.mysunrise.ch)
Date: Sat Jun 01 2002 - 00:38:24 EDT

  • Next message: Dick Fischer: "FWD: Hawkes Review"

    Wendee Holtcamp wrote (29 May 2002 14:57:14 -0500):
    >
    > Your signature intrigued me. What bible version are you using? And can you
    > tell me what original word is translated to evolve? I looked in my NIV and
    > it doesn't say anything I can find that would be similar. It is about God
    > rested from the work of creating. It must be "work"? I am intrigued because
    > I myself am an evolutionary creationist (ie I accept evolution and am a
    > Christian). I'd just be interested in knowing the background etc.

    Hi, Wendee,

    my e-mail signature, "..the work which God created to evolve it"
    (Genesis 2:3), is not from a particular published bible translation, but
    corresponds to a possible direct translation of the Hebrew text.

    The NIV Interlinear Hebrew-English Old Testament, ed. J.R. Kohlenberger
    III (Zondervan, Grand Rapids, MI, 1987) gives the last clause of Gen.2:3
    as: "... work-of-him that he-created God to-do", where each hyphenated
    expression corresponds to a single Hebrew word.

    In Hebrew, the verb "create" is "bara'", which designates the creation
    out of no preexisting entities. It occurs in the creation story of
    Gen.1:1 - 2:4 in the following verses only: 1:1, the creation of the
    physical universe; 1:21, the creation of "living souls", the water
    animals and the flying ones (i.e., the sentient or psychological realm);
    1:27, the creation of humans in God's image (i.e., the spiritual realm);
    and 2:4, the summary of the entire creation (referring back to 1:1 -
    2:3), which therefore does not represent still another (fourth) type of
    created entity.

    The verb translated "do" in 2:3, the Hebrew "^asah", is usually
    translated "make" and is used very often in the OT, for both God and
    humans. It designates making something out of a preexisting thing,
    substance, etc. Of course, this is the only way humans can make
    something.

    In A. Held & P. Ruest, "Genesis reconsidered", PSCF 51/4 (Dec. 1999),
    231-243; http://www.asa3.org/ASA/PSCF/1999/PSCF12-99Held.html, we wrote:

    "A frequent misunderstanding, not supported by the text, consists of
    seeing God's work in Genesis 1 as primarily miraculous. The Hebrew verb
    bara' (to create) designates exclusively divine creation of novelty.
    Three such creations are mentioned, the universe (1:1), animals (1:21),
    and humans (1:27), originating the physical, sentient, and spiritual
    realms. Between these events, developmental processes constituted the
    major part of what happened. Here, ^asah (to make, also used of humans)
    is typically found, implying the further 'preparation' or 'development'
    of preexisting entities. God saw that 'all that he prepared' [^asah] was
    'very good', and finished 'his work which he prepared'."

    There, we also explain in detail why we consider biological evolution to
    be one area or occurrence of this "making", or "developing" by God.
    Another passage from the same paper:

    "Is creation or evolution true? Both: the Bible links them inseparably.
    At the end of the 'creation story', the entire process is summarized:
    'These are the generations of the heavens and the earth in their being
    created'. The noun toledoth (generations) derives from the verb holid
    (to beget) and is a 'technical term' for lines of descent and family
    trees. Apparently, Genesis 1 is a register of descent, a genealogy, a
    phylogeny, containing words like seed, kinds, fruitful, multiply. Plant
    and animal groups appear sequentially in ascending order. As in other
    biblical genealogies known as 'tables of nations', which enumerate
    various branches descending from a common ancestor, no individual
    procreative acts are mentioned, but some important events - like the
    appearance of the dry land - are worked into Genesis 1."

    Peter

    -- 
    Dr. Peter Ruest, CH-3148 Lanzenhaeusern, Switzerland
    <pruest@dplanet.ch> - Biochemistry - Creation and evolution
    "..the work which God created to evolve it" (Genesis 2:3)
    



    This archive was generated by hypermail 2b29 : Sat Jun 01 2002 - 00:42:03 EDT