Re: ID

From: Wesley R. Elsberry (welsberr@inia.cls.org)
Date: Thu Jun 01 2000 - 11:06:51 EDT

  • Next message: Cliff Lundberg: "Re: ID"

    Stephen Jones wrote:

    [...]

    SJ>See above. Since ID is a *scientific* theory, there would
    SJ>be nothing wrong with it being taught in schools.

    People keep saying that, but also keep failing to point out
    how the claim is justified. Dembski has not made IDC concepts
    science yet, certainly.

    SJ>But I am not aware of anyone in the ID movement who is
    SJ>pushing for ID to be taught in schools.

    [...]

    Personal ignorance is not a reliable means of characterizing
    real world events. The Roger DeHart situation recently
    discussed here indicates heavy involvement of principals from
    the Discovery Institute's Center for Renewal of Science and
    Culture. Like Jonathan Wells' October 20, 1999 presentation
    at the Burlington-Edison High School. Like William Dembski's
    book signing in support of DeHart. The DI CRSC congressional
    briefing (also discussed here) was specifically aimed at
    influencing legislators concerning educational policy.
    <http://www.usnewswire.com/topnews/Current_Releases/0508-102.html>
    (Johnson, Meyer, Pearcey, and Behe as people in the IDC
    movement looking to push the teaching of ID in schools.
    Dembski, to his credit, withdrew from the briefing.)
    Following the Kansas Board of Education release of new
    standards, various indications of DI CRSC activity and
    activism were seen by many, but apparently not Stephen. Like
    Jay Wesley Richards' op ed piece (Darwinism and Design,
    Washington Post, Saturday, August 21, 1999; Page A19). Like
    the November 4, 1999 roundtable in Topeka, Kansas featuring
    Stephen Meyer, David DeWolf, and Jonathan Wells of the DI
    CRSC.

    I think one would have to be particularly inattentive to so
    blandly proclaim no personal knowledge of the extensive
    efforts of the DI CRSC to influence educational policy to push
    IDC through political process.

    Wesley



    This archive was generated by hypermail 2b29 : Thu Jun 01 2000 - 09:39:00 EDT