> However, in my opinion the abstract does not support your claim that there
> has never been a reducing or neutral atmosphere.
It constrains the "reducing atmosphere" model - pushing it back yet
further into the past.
> The data reported only
> goes back to 3 billion years, whereas the information from Mason that I
> reported in that very same post, in the section of the post you cut out,
> establishes that the earth had a strongly reducing atmosphere between 4.5
> and 4 billion years ago, followed by a weakly reducing atmosphere
> progressing to a neutral atmosphere between 4 and 3 billions years ago.
There is no evidence which "establishes" this, Kevin. This is
"theory" pretending to be data.
Further comment from me, on the paper cited by Art, is at:
http://www.pages.org/bcs/Bcs074.html
Best regards,
David J. Tyler.