Something similar *did* happen to me. I was raised baptist, but attended
public schools and had a *major* interest in science. When I went to college
I joined a non-denominational church, where one day the pastor preached
on evolution vs creation. During his sermon I had an epiphany. I recognized
that I had come to tacitly accept what `science' said about origins without
questioning it, and that `science' had betrayed that trust by so greatly
misrepresenting the situation.
I am still fascinated by the universe, and very interested in what
observations science has to make about it, but that day
a healthy distrust of `science' was born in me, and I have never
completely trusted science's interpretation of the data since.
--Dave